Figaro |
3 Comments |
Now in Italy and the UK and on e-book!
“Clever, passionate, and erudite.”
Publishers Weekly
Hear the NPR commentary.
Figaro rips the innards out of things people say and reveals the rhetorical tricks and pratfalls. For terms and definitions, click here.
(What are figures of speech?)
Ask Figaro a question!
Tuesday, July 8, 2008 at 05:04PM
Quote: “Don’t assume that because I don’t agree with you on something that it must be because I’m doing that politically.” Barack Obama, quoted in Reuters.
Figure of Speech: cacosyntheton (cak-o-SIN-the-ton), the bad speech. From the Greek, meaning “badly composed.”
When the silver-tongued Obama speaks badly, it’s news. He shows real discomfort in rebutting liberal accusations that he has flip-flopped on:
Dems have a reputation for their spinelessness, whether deserved or not, and a flip-flopping creature qualifies as an invertebrate. (You may think that McCain has been flip-flopping like a large-mouth bass on a slippery dock. But he’s a war hero and a Republican, which by definition means he is not spineless but flexible.)
So Obama must show good posture by refuting the flip-flopping charges every time he flip-flops. But here’s a rhetorical lesson: Watch when a normally articulate politician speaks with awkward syntax. It usually means he finds himself on shaky logical ground. Today’s quote uses a double negative, an isolated pronoun, and two pathetically dependent clauses to mean: I’m not being political. You just don’t like what I say.
Then again, Figaro used to be anti-flip-flopping, but now he’s for it. If only Bush had flip-flopped on Iraq a week before the invasion.
Snappy Answer: “You’re just saying that to be political.”
Reader Comments (3)
So maybe he is walking on shaky logical ground, in that he avoids the "flip flop" charge alltogether in his response.
Still, in some ways the awkward speech comes across as a sincere or unscripted statement. It sounds more off the cuff or spontaneous. It's also a more personal statement - it became a discussion between two individuals.
As you note yourself, the "flip flop" charge is easy to level at someone but by itself is a very weak type of claim.